The move was reportedly motivated by problems maintaining the metallic-blue finish over the course of a game:
The Giants staff has been actively seeking out ways of improving the performance and durability of their helmet coatings for quite some time and were interested in how the HGI HydroSkin® technology might be able to help them.If that was the intention, HGI fumbled.
The finishes looked great at the beginning of the game. I've been a fan of the Giants' helmet since it was unveiled in 2000, and in the beginning it appeared as though HGI got it just right.
Deep royal blue with metallic flake. Perfect.
As the game went on, the repeated impacts started to show.
On many players, particularly Manning and his receivers, the helmets continued to shine:
Linemen and other players who sustained repeated impacts throughout the game, however, were another matter. HGI's vaunted finsh showed every scrape and chip:
Whatever problems the Giants were having with their helmets before, surely they weren't this bad.
I guess this means we won't be seeing new metallic Packer helmets anytime soon. Back to the drawing board.